[DISCUSS] FLIP-131: Consolidate the user-facing Dataflow SDKs/APIs (and deprecate the DataSet API)

[Aljoscha Krettek]

Hi Everyone,

my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.

FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131

I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
document linked above for the full details:

--
Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
subsume the DataSet API's functionality.

In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
we maintain.
--

Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.

Best,
Aljoscha

[Márton Balassi]

Hi All,

Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the DataSet API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes necessary.

Best,

Marton

On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]> wrote:

Hi Everyone,

my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.

FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131

I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
document linked above for the full details:

--
Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
subsume the DataSet API's functionality.

In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
we maintain.
--

Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.

Best,
Aljoscha

[Arvid Heise-3]

+1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted for?

In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for switching back and forth.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <[hidden email]> wrote:

Hi All,

Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the DataSet API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes necessary.

Best,

Marton

On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]> wrote:

Hi Everyone,

my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.

FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131

I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
document linked above for the full details:

--
Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
subsume the DataSet API's functionality.

In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
we maintain.
--

Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.

Best,
Aljoscha

--

[Kurt Young]

+1, looking forward to the follow up FLIPs. 

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 6:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:

+1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted for?

In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
switching back and forth.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <[hidden email]>
wrote:

> Hi All,
>
> Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
> unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the DataSet
> API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
> necessary.
>
> Best,
> Marton
>
> On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]>
> wrote:
>
>> Hi Everyone,
>>
>> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
>> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
>> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
>> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
>>
>> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
>>
>> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
>> document linked above for the full details:
>>
>> --
>> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
>> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
>> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
>> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
>> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
>> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
>> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
>> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
>>
>> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
>> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
>> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
>> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
>> we maintain.
>> --
>>
>> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
>> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
>> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
>>
>> Best,
>> Aljoscha
>>
>

--

Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer

<https://www.ververica.com/>

Follow us @VervericaData

--

Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
Conference

Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time

--

Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany

--
Ververica GmbH
Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
(Toni) Cheng

[Till Rohrmann]

+1 for this effort. Great to see that we are making progress towards our goal of a truly unified batch and stream processing engine.

Cheers,
Till

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 2:28 PM Kurt Young <[hidden email]> wrote:

+1, looking forward to the follow up FLIPs. 

Best,

Kurt

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 6:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:

+1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted for?

In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
switching back and forth.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <[hidden email]>
wrote:

> Hi All,
>
> Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
> unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the DataSet
> API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
> necessary.
>
> Best,
> Marton
>
> On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]>
> wrote:
>
>> Hi Everyone,
>>
>> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
>> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
>> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
>> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
>>
>> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
>>
>> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
>> document linked above for the full details:
>>
>> --
>> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
>> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
>> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
>> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
>> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
>> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
>> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
>> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
>>
>> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
>> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
>> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
>> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
>> we maintain.
>> --
>>
>> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
>> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
>> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
>>
>> Best,
>> Aljoscha
>>
>

--

Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer

<https://www.ververica.com/>

Follow us @VervericaData

--

Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
Conference

Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time

--

Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany

--
Ververica GmbH
Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
(Toni) Cheng

[Flavio Pompermaier]

Just to contribute to the discussion, when we tried to do the migration we faced some problems that could make migration quite difficult.

1 - It's difficult to test because of https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-18647

2 - missing mapPartition 

3 - missing  <X> DataSet<X> runOperation(CustomUnaryOperation<T, X> operation)

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 12:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:

+1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted for?

In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
switching back and forth.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <[hidden email]>
wrote:

> Hi All,
>
> Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
> unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the DataSet
> API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
> necessary.
>
> Best,
> Marton
>
> On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]>
> wrote:
>
>> Hi Everyone,
>>
>> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
>> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
>> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
>> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
>>
>> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
>>
>> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
>> document linked above for the full details:
>>
>> --
>> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
>> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
>> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
>> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
>> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
>> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
>> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
>> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
>>
>> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
>> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
>> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
>> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
>> we maintain.
>> --
>>
>> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
>> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
>> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
>>
>> Best,
>> Aljoscha
>>
>

--

Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer

<https://www.ververica.com/>

Follow us @VervericaData

--

Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
Conference

Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time

--

Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany

--
Ververica GmbH
Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
(Toni) Cheng

[Seth Wiesman]

+1 Its time to drop DataSet

Flavio, those issues are expected. This FLIP isn't just to drop DataSet but to also add the necessary enhancements to DataStream such that it works well on bounded input.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 8:49 AM Flavio Pompermaier <[hidden email]> wrote:

Just to contribute to the discussion, when we tried to do the migration we
faced some problems that could make migration quite difficult.
1 - It's difficult to test because of
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-18647
2 - missing mapPartition
3 - missing  <X> DataSet<X> runOperation(CustomUnaryOperation<T, X>
operation)

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 12:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:

> +1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
> superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted for?
>
> In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
> switching back and forth.
>
> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <[hidden email]>
> wrote:
>
> > Hi All,
> >
> > Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
> > unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the
> DataSet
> > API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
> > necessary.
> >
> > Best,
> > Marton
> >
> > On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]>
> > wrote:
> >
> >> Hi Everyone,
> >>
> >> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
> >> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
> >> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
> >> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
> >>
> >> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
> >>
> >> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
> >> document linked above for the full details:
> >>
> >> --
> >> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
> >> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
> >> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
> >> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
> >> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
> >> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
> >> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
> >> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
> >>
> >> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
> >> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
> >> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
> >> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
> >> we maintain.
> >> --
> >>
> >> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
> >> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
> >> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
> >>
> >> Best,
> >> Aljoscha
> >>
> >
>
> --
>
> Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer
>
> <https://www.ververica.com/>
>
> Follow us @VervericaData
>
> --
>
> Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
> Conference
>
> Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time
>
> --
>
> Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany
>
> --
> Ververica GmbH
> Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
> Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
> (Toni) Cheng

[Flavio Pompermaier]

I just wanted to be propositive about missing api.. :D

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 4:29 PM Seth Wiesman <[hidden email]> wrote:

+1 Its time to drop DataSet

Flavio, those issues are expected. This FLIP isn't just to drop DataSet but to also add the necessary enhancements to DataStream such that it works well on bounded input.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 8:49 AM Flavio Pompermaier <[hidden email]> wrote:

Just to contribute to the discussion, when we tried to do the migration we
faced some problems that could make migration quite difficult.
1 - It's difficult to test because of
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-18647
2 - missing mapPartition
3 - missing  <X> DataSet<X> runOperation(CustomUnaryOperation<T, X>
operation)

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 12:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:

> +1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
> superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted for?
>
> In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
> switching back and forth.
>
> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <[hidden email]>
> wrote:
>
> > Hi All,
> >
> > Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
> > unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the
> DataSet
> > API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
> > necessary.
> >
> > Best,
> > Marton
> >
> > On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]>
> > wrote:
> >
> >> Hi Everyone,
> >>
> >> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
> >> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we have
> >> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's why
> >> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
> >>
> >> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
> >>
> >> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to the
> >> document linked above for the full details:
> >>
> >> --
> >> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs: Table
> >> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that this
> >> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in favor of
> >> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier said
> >> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that having
> >> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will then
> >> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API to
> >> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
> >>
> >> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how the
> >> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
> >> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will have to
> >> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs that
> >> we maintain.
> >> --
> >>
> >> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
> >> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki so
> >> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
> >>
> >> Best,
> >> Aljoscha
> >>
> >
>
> --
>
> Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer
>
> <https://www.ververica.com/>
>
> Follow us @VervericaData
>
> --
>
> Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
> Conference
>
> Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time
>
> --
>
> Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany
>
> --
> Ververica GmbH
> Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
> Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
> (Toni) Cheng

[Aljoscha Krettek]

That is good input! I was not aware that anyone was actually using
`runCustomOperation()`. Out of curiosity, what are you using that for?

We have definitely thought about the first two points you mentioned,
though. Especially processing-time will make it tricky to define unified
execution semantics.

Best,
Aljoscha

On 30.07.20 17:10, Flavio Pompermaier wrote:

> I just wanted to be propositive about missing api.. :D
>
> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 4:29 PM Seth Wiesman <[hidden email]> wrote:
>
>> +1 Its time to drop DataSet
>>
>> Flavio, those issues are expected. This FLIP isn't just to drop DataSet
>> but to also add the necessary enhancements to DataStream such that it works
>> well on bounded input.
>>
>> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 8:49 AM Flavio Pompermaier <[hidden email]>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> Just to contribute to the discussion, when we tried to do the migration we
>>> faced some problems that could make migration quite difficult.
>>> 1 - It's difficult to test because of
>>> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-18647
>>> 2 - missing mapPartition
>>> 3 - missing  <X> DataSet<X> runOperation(CustomUnaryOperation<T, X>
>>> operation)
>>>
>>> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 12:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:
>>>
>>>> +1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
>>>> superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted
>>> for?
>>>>
>>>> In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
>>>> switching back and forth.
>>>>
>>>> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <
>>> [hidden email]>
>>>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Hi All,
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
>>>>> unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the
>>>> DataSet
>>>>> API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
>>>>> necessary.
>>>>>
>>>>> Best,
>>>>> Marton
>>>>>
>>>>> On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <
>>> [hidden email]>
>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> Hi Everyone,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
>>>>>> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we
>>> have
>>>>>> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's
>>> why
>>>>>> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to
>>> the
>>>>>> document linked above for the full details:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> --
>>>>>> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs:
>>> Table
>>>>>> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that
>>> this
>>>>>> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in
>>> favor of
>>>>>> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier
>>> said
>>>>>> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that
>>> having
>>>>>> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will
>>> then
>>>>>> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API
>>> to
>>>>>> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how
>>> the
>>>>>> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
>>>>>> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will
>>> have to
>>>>>> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs
>>> that
>>>>>> we maintain.
>>>>>> --
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
>>>>>> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki
>>> so
>>>>>> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Best,
>>>>>> Aljoscha
>>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>>
>>>> Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer
>>>>
>>>> <https://www.ververica.com/>
>>>>
>>>> Follow us @VervericaData
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>>
>>>> Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
>>>> Conference
>>>>
>>>> Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>>
>>>> Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> Ververica GmbH
>>>> Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
>>>> Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
>>>> (Toni) Cheng
>>
>>
>

[Flavio Pompermaier]

We use runCustomOperation to group a set of operators and into a single functional unit, just to make the code more modular..

It's very comfortable indeed.

On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 5:20 PM Aljoscha Krettek <[hidden email]> wrote:

That is good input! I was not aware that anyone was actually using
`runCustomOperation()`. Out of curiosity, what are you using that for?

We have definitely thought about the first two points you mentioned,
though. Especially processing-time will make it tricky to define unified
execution semantics.

Best,
Aljoscha

On 30.07.20 17:10, Flavio Pompermaier wrote:
> I just wanted to be propositive about missing api.. :D
>
> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 4:29 PM Seth Wiesman <[hidden email]> wrote:
>
>> +1 Its time to drop DataSet
>>
>> Flavio, those issues are expected. This FLIP isn't just to drop DataSet
>> but to also add the necessary enhancements to DataStream such that it works
>> well on bounded input.
>>
>> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 8:49 AM Flavio Pompermaier <[hidden email]>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> Just to contribute to the discussion, when we tried to do the migration we
>>> faced some problems that could make migration quite difficult.
>>> 1 - It's difficult to test because of
>>> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-18647
>>> 2 - missing mapPartition
>>> 3 - missing  <X> DataSet<X> runOperation(CustomUnaryOperation<T, X>
>>> operation)
>>>
>>> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 12:40 PM Arvid Heise <[hidden email]> wrote:
>>>
>>>> +1 of getting rid of the DataSet API. Is DataStream#iterate already
>>>> superseding DataSet iterations or would that also need to be accounted
>>> for?
>>>>
>>>> In general, all surviving APIs should also offer a smooth experience for
>>>> switching back and forth.
>>>>
>>>> On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 9:39 AM Márton Balassi <
>>> [hidden email]>
>>>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Hi All,
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks for the write up and starting the discussion. I am in favor of
>>>>> unifying the APIs the way described in the FLIP and deprecating the
>>>> DataSet
>>>>> API. I am looking forward to the detailed discussion of the changes
>>>>> necessary.
>>>>>
>>>>> Best,
>>>>> Marton
>>>>>
>>>>> On Wed, Jul 29, 2020 at 12:46 PM Aljoscha Krettek <
>>> [hidden email]>
>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> Hi Everyone,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> my colleagues (in cc) and I would like to propose this FLIP for
>>>>>> discussion. In short, we want to reduce the number of APIs that we
>>> have
>>>>>> by deprecating the DataSet API. This is a big step for Flink, that's
>>> why
>>>>>> I'm also cross-posting this to the User Mailing List.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> FLIP-131: http://s.apache.org/FLIP-131
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I'm posting the introduction of the FLIP below but please refer to
>>> the
>>>>>> document linked above for the full details:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> --
>>>>>> Flink provides three main SDKs/APIs for writing Dataflow Programs:
>>> Table
>>>>>> API/SQL, the DataStream API, and the DataSet API. We believe that
>>> this
>>>>>> is one API too many and propose to deprecate the DataSet API in
>>> favor of
>>>>>> the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API. Of course, this is easier
>>> said
>>>>>> than done, so in the following, we will outline why we think that
>>> having
>>>>>> too many APIs is detrimental to the project and community. We will
>>> then
>>>>>> describe how we can enhance the Table API/SQL and the DataStream API
>>> to
>>>>>> subsume the DataSet API's functionality.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> In this FLIP, we will not describe all the technical details of how
>>> the
>>>>>> Table API/SQL and DataStream will be enhanced. The goal is to achieve
>>>>>> consensus on the idea of deprecating the DataSet API. There will
>>> have to
>>>>>> be follow-up FLIPs that describe the necessary changes for the APIs
>>> that
>>>>>> we maintain.
>>>>>> --
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Please let us know if you have any concerns or comments. Also, please
>>>>>> keep discussion to this ML thread instead of commenting in the Wiki
>>> so
>>>>>> that we can have a consistent view of the discussion.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Best,
>>>>>> Aljoscha
>>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>>
>>>> Arvid Heise | Senior Java Developer
>>>>
>>>> <https://www.ververica.com/>
>>>>
>>>> Follow us @VervericaData
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>>
>>>> Join Flink Forward <https://flink-forward.org/> - The Apache Flink
>>>> Conference
>>>>
>>>> Stream Processing | Event Driven | Real Time
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>>
>>>> Ververica GmbH | Invalidenstrasse 115, 10115 Berlin, Germany
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> Ververica GmbH
>>>> Registered at Amtsgericht Charlottenburg: HRB 158244 B
>>>> Managing Directors: Timothy Alexander Steinert, Yip Park Tung Jason, Ji
>>>> (Toni) Cheng
>>
>>
>

[Ashley32189]

Covid; 2017 - 2030 - Girls and Boys - Russian Family Incest - Private Video Collection
Young Girls and Boys Make Real Hot Sex on Cam; Private Video Collection:
ajb - Random Tiktok Girls -- Skype and Omegle Girls -- Tiktok Nude Girls
New Videos - New Movies - Movie Reviews - Movie Trailers -- TV
Russian Family Incest - Incest family teens
New Free Games - Private Sex Orgy - Self Teen Girls; ajb - Archive
Private Video Collection - Very Explicit Cams
18 yo Teens Only - Asian Tiktok Teens.
Home Made Model TKM -- Real Life Cam

Download from Xubster-com:
Link: https://xubster.com/users/546/9802

Download from Daofile-com:
Link: https://daofile.com/go/3w4soyhvuake

Download from Nelion-me:
Link: https://nelion.me/go/w98s182gorax

Download from File-al:
Link: https://file.al/public/56284/31885

-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_

Log In or Sign Up; Link: https://xubster.com/free546.html

Amateur Young Girls
Link; 1: https://xubster.com/users/546/12421/0001
Link; 2: https://xubster.com/users/546/12462/0002
Link; 3: https://xubster.com/users/546/12463/0003
Link; 4: https://xubster.com/users/546/12464/0004
Link; 5: https://xubster.com/users/546/12465/0005
Link; 6: https://xubster.com/users/546/12466/0006
Link; 7: https://xubster.com/users/546/12467/0007
Link; 8: https://xubster.com/users/546/12468/0008
Link; 9: https://xubster.com/users/546/12469/0009
Link; 10: https://xubster.com/users/546/12470/0010
Link; 11: https://xubster.com/users/546/12471/0011
Link; 12: https://xubster.com/users/546/12472/0012

Covid: 2017 - 2030 - Girls and Boys
Link; 13: https://xubster.com/users/546/12422/0013
Link; 14: https://xubster.com/users/546/12473/0014

18 yo Teens Only
Innocent sweethearts star in 18 year old sex scenes
with their tight cunts filled by big cocks
Sexy coeds give hot blowjobs and swallow cum
Teens, Hardcore, Large Shlong, Amateur eighteen Years Old
18 year old masturbates on cam
Horny Teen 19 Years Old Masturbating On Web Cam
Only fingers filling my pussy to orgasm
Link; 15: https://xubster.com/users/546/12423/0015
Link; 16: https://xubster.com/users/546/12474/0016
Link; 17: https://xubster.com/users/546/12475/0017
Link; 18: https://xubster.com/users/546/12476/0018
Link; 19: https://xubster.com/users/546/12477/0019

Asian Tiktok Teens
Link; 20: https://xubster.com/users/546/12424/0020
Link; 21: https://xubster.com/users/546/12479/0021
Link; 22: https://xubster.com/users/546/12480/0022
Link; 23: https://xubster.com/users/546/12481/0023
Link; 24: https://xubster.com/users/546/12482/0024
Link; 25: https://xubster.com/users/546/12483/0025
Link; 26: https://xubster.com/users/546/12484/0026
Link; 27: https://xubster.com/users/546/12485/0027
Link; 28: https://xubster.com/users/546/12486/0028
Link; 29: https://xubster.com/users/546/12487/0029
Link; 30: https://xubster.com/users/546/12488/0030
Link; 31: https://xubster.com/users/546/12489/0031

Real Life Cam
Teen and Young Girls and Couples
Voyeur Villa Nelly Doggystyle HD Sex
Real Private Life on WebCam
Categories: Voyeur Sex, WebCam Porn, SpyCam Fetish
Teen Cam, Young Couples, Exhibitionism Video, Young Public Sex
WebCam Public Sex, Masturbation Teens, TeenSex
Link; 32: https://xubster.com/users/546/12418/0032
Link; 33: https://xubster.com/users/546/12490/0033
Link; 34: https://xubster.com/users/546/12491/0034
Link; 35: https://xubster.com/users/546/12492/0035
Link; 36: https://xubster.com/users/546/12493/0036
Link; 37: https://xubster.com/users/546/12494/0037

Porn Tiktok 18+ Banned on TikTok
Link; 38: https://xubster.com/users/546/12592/0038
Link; 39: https://xubster.com/users/546/12593/0039
Link; 40: https://xubster.com/users/546/12594/0040
Link; 41: https://xubster.com/users/546/12595/0041
Link; 42: https://xubster.com/users/546/12596/0042
Link; 43: https://xubster.com/users/546/12597/0043
Link; 44: https://xubster.com/users/546/12598/0044
Link; 45: https://xubster.com/users/546/12599/0045
Link; 46: https://xubster.com/users/546/12600/0046
Link; 47: https://xubster.com/users/546/12601/0047
Link; 48: https://xubster.com/users/546/12602/0048
Link; 49: https://xubster.com/users/546/12603/0049
Link; 50: https://xubster.com/users/546/12604/0050

Teen Models
Japanese Teen Girl in WebCam Show After School
MISS VIKKI - TEEN RUSSIAN MODEL
Little Miss Vikki From Russia -- My Private Collection
Mattie Doll -- Horny Teen With a Talent for Sharing Sensational Orgasmes
Kyutty Kitty -- Asian Sweety PussyCat
REAL VIDEOS OF SEXY TEEN MODEL Hentai-Cat
Effy Loweell -- Sexy Young Models With Small Tits

Alice MFC
Link; 51: https://xubster.com/users/546/12427

Alison Lil Baby
Link; 52: https://xubster.com/users/546/12428

Cute Mary
Link; 53: https://xubster.com/users/546/12429

Effy Loweell
Link; 54: https://xubster.com/users/546/12430

Hana Lily
Link; 55: https://xubster.com/users/546/12431

Hentai-Cat
Link; 56: https://xubster.com/users/546/12432

Hot Nesquik
Link; 57: https://xubster.com/users/546/12433

Katya Letova
Link; 58: https://xubster.com/users/546/12434

Koska Leska
Link; 59: https://xubster.com/users/546/12435

Kyutty
Link; 60: https://xubster.com/users/546/12436

Mattie Doll
Link; 61: https://xubster.com/users/546/12437

Miss Vikki
Link; 62: https://xubster.com/users/546/12438

Venus Kitty
Link; 63: https://xubster.com/users/546/12439

Your Wet Schoolgirl
Link; 64: https://xubster.com/users/546/12440

Non Nude Tiktok Teens
Teen Cute Girls talk, sexy dance and play on cam
Link; 65: https://xubster.com/users/546/12452/0065
Link; 66: https://xubster.com/users/546/12507/0066
Link; 67: https://xubster.com/users/546/12508/0067
Link; 68: https://xubster.com/users/546/12509/0068
Link; 69: https://xubster.com/users/546/12510/0069
Link; 70: https://xubster.com/users/546/12511/0070
Link; 71: https://xubster.com/users/546/12512/0071
Link; 72: https://xubster.com/users/546/12513/0072
Link; 73: https://xubster.com/users/546/12514/0073
Link; 74: https://xubster.com/users/546/12515/0074
Link; 75: https://xubster.com/users/546/12516/0075
Link; 76: https://xubster.com/users/546/12517/0076

Nudism Young Girls
Link; 77: https://xubster.com/users/546/12453/0077
Link; 78: https://xubster.com/users/546/12518/0078
Link; 79: https://xubster.com/users/546/12519/0079
Link; 80: https://xubster.com/users/546/12520/0080
Link; 81: https://xubster.com/users/546/12521/0081
Link; 82: https://xubster.com/users/546/12522/0082
Link; 83: https://xubster.com/users/546/12523/0083

Russian Family Incest
Incest family teens
Link; 84: https://xubster.com/users/546/12454/0084
Link; 85: https://xubster.com/users/546/12524/0085
Link; 86: https://xubster.com/users/546/12525/0086
Link; 87: https://xubster.com/users/546/12526/0087
Link; 88: https://xubster.com/users/546/12527/0088
Link; 89: https://xubster.com/users/546/12528/0089
Link; 90: https://xubster.com/users/546/12529/0090
Link; 91: https://xubster.com/users/546/12530/0091

Real Spycam - Hiddencam
Link; 92: https://xubster.com/users/546/12455/0092
Link; 93: https://xubster.com/users/546/12531/0093
Link; 94: https://xubster.com/users/546/12532/0094
Link; 95: https://xubster.com/users/546/12533/0095
Link; 96: https://xubster.com/users/546/12534/0096
Link; 97: https://xubster.com/users/546/12535/0097
Link; 98: https://xubster.com/users/546/12536/0098
Link; 99: https://xubster.com/users/546/12537/0099
Link; 100: https://xubster.com/users/546/12538/0100
Link; 101: https://xubster.com/users/546/12539/0101
Link; 102: https://xubster.com/users/546/12540/0102
Link; 103: https://xubster.com/users/546/12541/0103

Tight Teen Pussy
FUCK TIGHT TEEN PUSSY - Real Fuck Extreme Small Teen Pussy - 18+
FULL HD 83 Hot Home Made Videos of Real Extreme Fuck Small Teen Pussy
Link; 104: https://xubster.com/users/546/12456/0104

Random Tiktok Girls
Link; 105: https://xubster.com/users/546/12457/0105
Link; 106: https://xubster.com/users/546/12542/0106
Link; 107: https://xubster.com/users/546/12543/0107
Link; 108: https://xubster.com/users/546/12544/0108
Link; 109: https://xubster.com/users/546/12545/0109
Link; 110: https://xubster.com/users/546/12546/0110
Link; 111: https://xubster.com/users/546/12547/0111
Link; 112: https://xubster.com/users/546/12548/0112
Link; 113: https://xubster.com/users/546/12549/0113
Link; 114: https://xubster.com/users/546/12550/0114
Link; 115: https://xubster.com/users/546/12551/0115
Link; 116: https://xubster.com/users/546/12552/0116
Link; 117: https://xubster.com/users/546/12553/0117
Link; 118: https://xubster.com/users/546/12554/0118

Skype and Omegle Girls
Link; 119: https://xubster.com/users/546/12459/0119
Link; 120: https://xubster.com/users/546/12555/0120
Link; 121: https://xubster.com/users/546/12556/0121
Link; 122: https://xubster.com/users/546/12557/0122
Link; 123: https://xubster.com/users/546/12558/0123
Link; 124: https://xubster.com/users/546/12559/0124
Link; 125: https://xubster.com/users/546/12560/0125
Link; 126: https://xubster.com/users/546/12561/0126
Link; 127: https://xubster.com/users/546/12562/0127
Link; 128: https://xubster.com/users/546/12563/0128
Link; 129: https://xubster.com/users/546/12564/0129
Link; 130: https://xubster.com/users/546/12565/0130

Tiktok Nude Girls
Link; 131: https://xubster.com/users/546/12460/0131
Link; 132: https://xubster.com/users/546/12566/0132
Link; 133: https://xubster.com/users/546/12567/0133
Link; 134: https://xubster.com/users/546/12568/0134
Link; 135: https://xubster.com/users/546/12569/0135
Link; 136: https://xubster.com/users/546/12570/0136
Link; 137: https://xubster.com/users/546/12571/0137
Link; 138: https://xubster.com/users/546/12572/0138
Link; 139: https://xubster.com/users/546/12573/0139
Link; 140: https://xubster.com/users/546/12574/0140
Link; 141: https://xubster.com/users/546/12575/0141
Link; 142: https://xubster.com/users/546/12576/0142
Link; 143: https://xubster.com/users/546/12577/0143
Link; 144: https://xubster.com/users/546/12578/0144
Link; 145: https://xubster.com/users/546/12579/0145

Webcam Teens and Couples
Link; 146: https://xubster.com/users/546/12461/0146
Link; 147: https://xubster.com/users/546/12580/0147
Link; 148: https://xubster.com/users/546/12581/0148
Link; 149: https://xubster.com/users/546/12582/0149
Link; 150: https://xubster.com/users/546/12583/0150
Link; 151: https://xubster.com/users/546/12584/0151
Link; 152: https://xubster.com/users/546/12585/0152
Link; 153: https://xubster.com/users/546/12586/0153
Link; 154: https://xubster.com/users/546/12587/0154
Link; 155: https://xubster.com/users/546/12588/0155
Link; 156: https://xubster.com/users/546/12589/0156
Link; 157: https://xubster.com/users/546/12590/0157

Rape Porn; Free Porn Videos; HD - VR Sex Videos
Link; 158: https://xubster.com/users/546/6261/001

Snuff Porn Videos; Fake murders and decapitation
Link; 159: https://xubster.com/users/546/6265/002

Forced Porn; Forced Sex - Forced To Fuck Videos
Link; 160: https://xubster.com/users/546/6266/003

Hot Asian Teen Sex Videos; Japanese and Korean Porn Movies
Link; 161: https://xubster.com/users/546/6262/004

Sleeping Girl Gets An Unexpected Visit Late At Night
Sex Sleeping Girl Porn Videos
Link; 162: https://xubster.com/users/546/6296/005

Lesbian Necrophilia Porn Videos
Link; 163: https://xubster.com/users/546/6290/006

Horror Porn Videos - Sex Movies
Link; 164: https://xubster.com/users/546/6295/007

Sex Gay Porn Videos
Link; 165: https://xubster.com/users/546/6281/008

:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:

3D, Hentai, Free Games

Download from Daofile.com:
Link: https://daofile.com/go/p47ssveuv75c

Sex Cartoons; Free Games; Hentai; Manga; 3D

Download: MegaPack; 367249 Files:
Link: https://file.al/public/56284/38916

:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:

Preview Video
Link: https://xubster.com/users/546/12061

HD Young Nudists PN Videos

Download from Xubster.com:
Link: https://xubster.com/users/546/12062
Link: https://xubster.com/users/546/12067

PN Teen Girls; Young Adult Nudism; Teen Nudist Sex:

Download: MegaPack; 83150 Files:
Link: https://file.al/public/56284/38915

:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:

Private Collection; Real Teen Sexy Selfies and Videos

Download: MegaPack; 192851 Files:
Link: https://file.al/public/56284/38917

:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:

Preview Video
Link: https://daofile.com/go/efb4i0wyu73a

TukTuk Patrol - Thai Teen Video:

Download from Daofile.com:
Link: https://daofile.com/go/0ackk6rwv5gq

:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:

Girls and Boys PT - Photo and Video

Download: MegaPack; 531498 Files:
Link: https://file.al/public/56284/39650

:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:-:

VIP: - Young Nude Vagina
Link; 1: https://daofile.com/go/58017o3w2wa1

VIP: - Taboo Teen Archive
Link; 2: https://daofile.com/go/at6nq7tzdrwq
Link; 3: https://daofile.com/go/uqvdfvlt1b7j

VIP: - Private Sex Orgy; - Self Teen Girls
Link; 4: https://daofile.com/go/rwmcfthjrcew
Link; 5: https://daofile.com/go/7x4q0mtks6bo

Young Teen Bathing Suit Videos and HD Footage
Asian Woman In Bathroom Videos and HD Footage
Japanese Bath Culture, Public Bath
Link; 6: https://daofile.com/go/zvcjqfm0s50w
Link; 7: https://daofile.com/go/62mt4oaxq78n
Link; 8: https://daofile.com/go/x1q0iheql2ym
Link; 9: https://daofile.com/go/c9d7xs7fsme6
Link; 10: https://daofile.com/go/0pza6o1prc3r
Link; 11: https://daofile.com/go/s6qkgi10c7tf
Link; 12: https://daofile.com/go/1mg548npuj9p
Link; 13: https://daofile.com/go/piif3sxzu7y4

Japanese Teen HD Sex Porn Videos
Japanese School Girl Full Movie Porn videos
Japanese teen jav xxx sex school asian big tits milf mom sister porn HD
Link; 14: https://daofile.com/go/ws3qwum15koi
Link; 15: https://daofile.com/go/z9k8qssuw74c
Link; 16: https://daofile.com/go/r2pmntlq6vkp
Link; 17: https://daofile.com/go/r9khigu0c0xe
Link; 18: https://daofile.com/go/5qfkaafzvk0k
Link; 19: https://daofile.com/go/st4jcfg1g9bz
Link; 20: https://daofile.com/go/4hvigt8dchbc

Selfie teens
Real teens sexy selfies, show teen tits
Link; 21: https://daofile.com/go/dlfstx2s3mv3
Link; 22: https://daofile.com/go/3i181cjpm77j
Link; 23: https://daofile.com/go/ccyhj01bdnmg
Link; 24: https://daofile.com/go/gh7snep8cn54

Collection of Teen Sex and Erotic Videos
Link; 25: https://daofile.com/go/kun7aw1l0sxy
Link; 26: https://daofile.com/go/u9jikdewbmen
Link; 27: https://daofile.com/go/sxflclskqlde
Link; 28: https://daofile.com/go/htsmkg04kkop
Link; 29: https://daofile.com/go/daq9svwypcpg
Link; 30: https://daofile.com/go/d26g52rcnyql
Link; 31: https://daofile.com/go/4msqlcw96jyf
Link; 32: https://daofile.com/go/a6vapjguf0x7
Link; 33: https://daofile.com/go/937pupbznnt1

Webcam Teen
Teen Erotic Videos From Real Life Cams - Omegle teen, Skype teen
Link; 34: https://daofile.com/go/e2nnzbuhjt5z
Link; 35: https://daofile.com/go/nz1tewuygcr1
Link; 36: https://daofile.com/go/23sfxojnkhlc
Link; 37: https://daofile.com/go/31lpybl6312o
Link; 38: https://daofile.com/go/ahtftflfq6gl
Link; 39: https://daofile.com/go/5xcpj94xj6tw
Link; 40: https://daofile.com/go/gyshuzhg00l8
Link; 41: https://daofile.com/go/kr3zaonpkf4p
Link; 42: https://daofile.com/go/cl923bdxvs9k
Link; 43: https://daofile.com/go/3burlwssg7py
Link; 44: https://daofile.com/go/e12thco5doao

Young Girls and Boys Make Real Hot Sex on Cam
Link; 45: https://daofile.com/go/k0ws7lypjw5c
Link; 46: https://daofile.com/go/w96f0hj7ym8t

Sex Machine Porn Videos
Link; 47: https://daofile.com/go/psc0hbsfch2w
Link; 48: https://daofile.com/go/xet9s4b8l1n0

Candy-Dolls; Teen Crazy Girls Gallery
Link; 49: https://daofile.com/go/ka68my4wdqca
Link; 50: https://daofile.com/go/wwiaf2oaavgp

Toilet HD Videos - Hidden cams in toilets film every amateur comer
Watch Public toilet spy cam of girls pissing of Best Collection Voyeur Porn videos
Medical And Gyno Voyeur Videos
Watch Medical voyeur cam shooting
Asian explored in the gyno office of Best Collection Voyeur Porn videos
Link; 51: https://daofile.com/go/71feh10vjrfe
Link; 52: https://daofile.com/go/osxvp1epjyam
Link; 53: https://daofile.com/go/ylhuc48hu73l
Link; 54: https://daofile.com/go/5lx4gmnok82y
Link; 55: https://daofile.com/go/u13oih6vbrjc
Link; 56: https://daofile.com/go/s3a5qk1p5cyw

Tokyo-Dolls - Sexy Teen Girls - Full Collection
Link; 57: https://daofile.com/go/y9w47mnulyw1

Galitsin Teen - TP Sex Videos i7149
Link; 58: https://daofile.com/go/6uttrr3le10n
Link; 59: https://daofile.com/go/sjatsg7tjroi
Link; 60: https://daofile.com/go/1gx4d40cf40w
Link; 61: https://daofile.com/go/mu8hlmao4fge
Link; 62: https://daofile.com/go/phu0sv1tgx9c
Link; 63: https://daofile.com/go/z6oa86xp644b

Candid HD
Link; 64: https://daofile.com/go/1piz0c48n4p3

Femdom BDSM;
Link; 65: https://daofile.com/go/u6w29zcyys0c

Nonude Models
Link; 66: https://daofile.com/go/nnxix879th8k

Nudi-Pageant
Link; 67: https://daofile.com/go/nxnme8zrveru

TTL and YFM Teen Latinas Models
Link; 68: http://daofile.com/go/wlpk7947rax3

*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*
.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*

Covid; 2017 - 2030 - Girls and Boys - Russian Family Incest - Private Video Collection
Young Girls and Boys Make Real Hot Sex on Cam; Private Video Collection:
ajb - Random Tiktok Girls -- Skype and Omegle Girls -- Tiktok Nude Girls
New Videos - New Movies - Movie Reviews - Movie Trailers - TV
Russian Family Incest - Incest family teens
New Free Games - Private Sex Orgy - Self Teen Girls; ajb - Archive
Private Video Collection - Very Explicit Cams
18 yo Teens Only - Asian Tiktok Teens
Home Made Model TKM -- Real Life Cam

Download from Xubster-com:
Link: https://xubster.com/users/546/9802

Download from Daofile-com:
Link: https://daofile.com/go/3w4soyhvuake

Download from Nelion-me:
Link: https://nelion.me/go/w98s182gorax

Download from File-al:
Link: https://file.al/public/56284/31885

___________________
___________________

Young Girls and Boys Make Real Hot Sex on Cam